18 Comments
User's avatar
Barbara Shoup's avatar

I love how one thing leads to another!

How weird that DGP might have been your neighbor:-)

Expand full comment
Robyn Ryle's avatar

Got my copy from the library. Almost finished and loving it so much. But also, the murdered author, David Graham Phillips, is from Madison and I had no idea. He grew up in one of the houses just around the corner, which is, of course, still there. Going to check out his biography now, though probably not read one of his novels. I'll trust Edith Wharton's opinion on their quality. Thanks again for writing about this book!

Expand full comment
Barbara Shoup's avatar

It's a close call! But, yeah, I think so.

Expand full comment
Dan Patterson's avatar

What a great experience and NYT article. Even better than visiting Jim's grave in Paris?

Expand full comment
Barbara Shoup's avatar

Thanks!

Expand full comment
Carrie F. Smith's avatar

This is a wonderful piece. And I feel sure that you were the reason for that letter to the editor!

Expand full comment
Barbara Shoup's avatar

Thanks. It really was a wonderful experience.

Expand full comment
Barbara Shoup's avatar

Elementary Ed :-)

Expand full comment
Rita Dragonette's avatar

Wonderful. I adore Wharton.

What was your major if not English?

Expand full comment
Barbara Shoup's avatar

Thanks. It really was.

Expand full comment
The World According to Grace's avatar

I love this story so much, Barb! What a cool experience.

Expand full comment
MARY BLARY's avatar

I loved this, too, Barb. Especially your visit to her grave and the care you gave her and the grave. Your finding her humor in the two lonely begonias was wonderful! I want to read both Wharton and this book! Thanks!

Expand full comment
Barbara Shoup's avatar

I loved doing that!

Expand full comment
Barbara Shoup's avatar

It really was a lovely experience. Glad you enjoyed it.

Expand full comment
Mary Sexson's avatar

I LOVE this story! I needed to read it on this otherwise uneventful Monday morning. And that you found a piece of glass to dig a hole to put the flowers in was perfect.

Expand full comment
Mary Redman's avatar

Sounds intriguing. Most of all, though, I enjoy your story about caring for Wharton’s grave. I can just see you there, Barb.

Expand full comment